Fire Island Average Sale Price By Community

The Fire Island real estate market is still going strong.  Our firm is on pace for another record year in 2017 and we want to thank all of our wonderful clients!  We believe in the importance of a data driven approach and we know reliable market data can be hard to come by on Fire Island.  Our annual Market Report will come out after year end, but in the meantime, we wanted to provide you with some year to date average sale data to tide you over.

Below are average recorded sale prices so far this year, by community:

Ocean Beach $770,130
Seaview $915,000
Ocean Bay Park $622,438
Robbins Rest $1,250,000
Corneille Estates $840,000
Lonelyville $775,000
Kismet $708,800
Cherry Grove $479,000
Davis Park $705,000
Fair Harbor $743,750
Fire Island Pines $877,143
Saltaire $897,657
Water Island $1,200,000

Please note that there is a lag between the time when sales actually close, are recorded in public records, and then become available to us through our data service, so there may be some closed sales not yet factored in to the above statistics.