The Fire Island Market in 2025: Prices Keep Climbing, But the Playing Field Has Shifted By: Abigail Mago Licensed Broker, Fire Island Sales & Rentals | Market Intelligence | May 2026 If you've been watching the Fire Island real estate market over the past few years, you may have noticed something that can feel almost […]

Fire Island Sales & Rentals’ Rainy Day Must Haves! Fire Island is known for its beaches, boating, and boardwalks, but what happens when it rains? Here's your guide to enjoying Fire Island even when the skies are gray! 1. Gear Up: Rainy Day Essentials You’ll still want to get around—even in a drizzle. Here’s what […]

Prime Day Steals You Can’t Miss! Fire Island Sales & Rentals’ Beach House Must Haves In honor of Amazon Prime Day, we’re sharing our favorite beach essentials.  Whether you’re just visiting Fire Island for a week vacation, or you’re lucky enough to live here all Summer long, these are some our favorite finds that every […]

When is the best time to book your Summer rental? Fire Island lovers who are looking now to book their Summer rental are certainly not looking too early! The sooner you look & book, the more available inventory there is to choose from, so we recommend you start looking into your summer rental plans now!  […]

By: Alyssa O'Keefe and Abigail Mago With the colder weather moving in, a day at the beach may be the furthest thing from your mind. However, if you have been considering purchasing a beach house, the “off season” is one of the best times to do so! Here are five reasons why now is the […]

In recent years, the debate of traditionally renting out your home (i.e. through a real estate agent) versus renting through popular vacation booking sites, like AirBnB and VRBO, has received more attention as the vacation rental industry continues to become more popular. We believe when renting out your beach house, there are many more benefits […]

Cleaning: Give the whole space a deep clean before the rental season begins! Routine Maintenance of AC & Appliances: To avoid having to make maintenance calls while renters are at your home, it’s worth checking to make sure the AC’s work and if any air filters need to be replaced before your first rental checks […]

Congratulations!  You listed your home, accepted an offer and went under contract.  Now what?  Below is a list of items to tackle ahead of closing to ensure a smooth transaction.  Please do not hesitate to reach out to us at Fire Island Real Estate if you need any further assistance with these task items.  We […]

By: Abigail Mago, Licensed Associate Broker I think it’s safe to say that 2020 has been a wild year for everyone. Despite the economic chaos brought on by the pandemic, the Fire Island real estate market has flourished this year. While we won’t have a complete data set to analyze the full year’s performance until […]